Lot No: 4750

Estimate(RMB): 200,000-300,000

Price Realized(RMB): --

此本为整纸淡墨本,皮纸精拓,与石门摩崖早期拓本如《大开通》未剜本、《石门颂》“高”字本、《石门铭》“此”字本纸墨类似,神完气足,应为同一时期拓本。据宋松、王欣二位《汉杨淮表纪拓本考》一文(载《书法丛刊》2020年第4期),刻石拓本由早及晚分为“当隶”未损本、“郎”字完好本、“郎”字已泐本、“黄”字半损本、“黄”字草头本和“约”字已损本六种版本。最早版本“当、隶”未损本时间在清早期,其有“黄”字本典型特征如下:1.首行“尚书侍郎”之“郎”字左下方可见一片向上凸起的石皮层,其顶端为半圆弧状;2.五行“功德牟盛”之“牟”字,该字“厶”部与“牛”间有一呈四边形的笔划空隙区域,表现在拓本上是一处小色块。早本为近长方形的形状,稍晚本则是小倒梯形,其面积较早本泐损少许;3.五行“当究三事”之“当”字,该字下部 “田”字左下有一小石皮层,早本呈拇指,顶端较平,晚拓皆损伤变小;4.六行“司隶”之“隶”字,早本笔划明显,右部撇画与捺画清晰,两笔交叉处上方有一椭圆形小石斑,稍晚本则笔划交叉处模糊不清,椭圆形小石斑已脱落不见,再晚本则“隶”字右下部已损伤。此本即《汉杨淮表纪拓本考》论文所刊登之图三底本,依考据点定为清早期淡墨最旧“当隶”未损本。又前人有关《杨淮表记》的鉴定主要围绕末行首“黄”字展开,如方若《校碑随笔》云:“旧拓本末行无黄门之黄字,翁氏《两汉金石记》阙之,王氏《金石萃编》补足之。今据拓本黄字固未泐,盖当时遗拓也。”张彦生先生《善本碑帖录》载:“见白棉纸旧拓本,末行黄门卞玉等字完好。道光间拓本黄门卞玉等字失拓,近拓黄字只存上少半,下大半石裂损”。其见解是“黄”字完好者早于“黄”字失拓的道光拓本。马子云先生的看法是最早康雍间拓本无“黄”字,较晚拓本有“黄”字或“黄”字下大半,王壮弘先生《增补校碑随笔》载:“乾隆前拓本,黄门、卞玉四字完好然此四字往往失拓,近百年拓本“黄”字只存上半,下半裂损。”然观察原石末行黄字正当凹处,早期拓本中一类无“黄”字本应为拓工粗率失拓或是为图省事不拓所致,撇开“黄”字这个传统但并不可靠的考据,看其他几处新发现的考据并结合纸墨特征来鉴定杨淮表记拓本的早晚更为可靠。著录:1. 《汉杨淮表记拓本考》,《书法丛刊》2020年第4期。参阅:1.《碑帖鉴定概论(增订本)》P153-154,上海古籍出版社,2023。2. 《中国碑刻全集》编委会:《中国碑刻全集》第二卷P69~96,人民美术出版社,2010。HAN YANG HUAI BIAO JI MO YAInk-rubbing in early Qing Dynasty1 pieceLiterature: Han Yang Hai Biao Ji Ta Ben Kao, Calligraphy Series, issue no. 4, 2020192×59.5cmRMB: 200,000-300,000
Copyright statement

All contents published on the website of Xiling Yinshe Auction Co., Ltd. ("XYA"), including but not limited to, text reports, pictures, sound, videos, charts, logos, advertisements, trademarks, trade names, domain names, software, programs, layout designs, column directories and names, content classification standards, and any or all information provided to registered users, are protected by the Copyright Law of the People's Republic of China, the Trademark Law of the People's Republic of China, the Patent Law of the People's Republic of China, and applicable international conventions related to copyright, trademark, patent, and/or other property rights laws, and owned by XYA and/or the related rights holders.

Except as expressly permitted by XYA, no person may modify, issue, broadcast, reprint, copy, reproduce, alter, distribute, perform, display, or use part or all of the contents or services on the XYA's website or mirror them on servers not belonging to XYA. Any such use without XYA's prior written authorization is strictly prohibited and constitutes an infringement of XYA's exclusive rights. XYA holds all rights to the software used on its website, including but not limited to the computer programs, layout designs, and other software components. The software is protected by the Copyright Law of the People's Republic of China, the Computer Software Protection Regulations, and international copyright conventions. Any use of the software, including but not limited to copying, modifying, distributing, dumping, publishing, displaying, demonstrating, or reverse engineering, is strictly prohibited unless specifically authorized by XYA for sales, free downloads, or other purposes.

Special statement

Any person who uses the images and derivatives of the auction items displayed on the XYA's website for personal consumption purposes that are non-commercial, non-profit, and non-advertising, or for commercial, profit-making, and advertising purposes, shall obtain the written authorization of XYA and/or relevant rights holders in accordance with the Copyright Law and other relevant laws without infringement of the rights of XYA and/or relevant rights holders.